Interview with Robert Newman — At the Old North Church, 193 Salem Street, Boston, Massachusetts
Boston, Massachusetts — The Old North Church, 193 Salem Street, North End
Look up at the steeple.
It rises 191 feet above Salem Street in Boston’s North End — the tallest point in the city when it was built in 1723, visible from the harbor, visible from Charlestown across the water, visible from miles away on a clear night. That height was part of the design. The Old North Church was built as an Anglican church, the official religion of the English Crown, planted in the heart of a Puritan colony as a reminder of who held authority here. The steeple was meant to be seen.
It would be seen in a very different way on the night of April 18, 1775.
Almost everyone knows the story — or thinks they do. One if by land, two if by sea. Paul Revere’s midnight ride. The regulars are coming. Longfellow’s poem cemented it all into American legend so thoroughly that the details have blurred at the edges, smoothed into myth. But the real story is more interesting than the legend, and the man at the center of the real story is almost entirely forgotten.
His name was Robert Newman. He was the sexton of the Old North Church — the caretaker, responsible for the building’s upkeep and the ringing of its bells. He was not a military man, not a political organizer, not a famous name in the revolutionary networks. He was the man who knew the church. He knew its doors and its locks and its dark stairwells and its high steeple. And on the night that mattered most, that knowledge was exactly what was needed.
The lantern signal — one if by land, two if by sea — was not Paul Revere’s primary plan. It was his contingency. Revere and the other riders intended to carry the warning themselves, in person, by horse. But the British were watching. Riders might be stopped. Riders might be arrested. If the messengers were intercepted and the warning never reached the militias gathering in Lexington and Concord, everything would be lost. The lanterns were the backup — a brief flash of light from the highest point in Boston, visible across the water to Charlestown, carrying the message in seconds even if every rider on the road was captured.
The man they trusted to climb that steeple in the dark, alone, and hang those lanterns at exactly the right moment was Robert Newman.
Note: The following interview is fictionalized but grounded in documented history.
The Interview
Dan: Hello, everyone! I am standing inside the Old North Church at 193 Salem Street in Boston’s North End — the oldest church in the city and one of the most important sites in the story of American independence. Today I am honored to sit down with the man who actually climbed this steeple on the night of April 18, 1775 — the man who hung the lanterns. Welcome, Robert Newman.
Robert Newman: Thank you, Dan. I’ll admit it is strange to be remembered at all. Most people who know this church know Paul Revere’s name. Mine tends to get left out of the poem.
Dan: That poem has a lot to answer for. But let’s start before the night itself. Tell me about this church. You were the sexton here — what did that mean, day to day?
Robert Newman: I was the caretaker. I maintained the building — the floors, the pews, the bells, the locks. I opened the church in the morning and secured it at night. I knew every door, every hinge, every staircase from the ground floor to the top of the steeple. The sexton’s job is not a glamorous one. But it is an essential one. A church does not run without someone who knows it completely and tends to it faithfully.
Dan: And Paul Revere was a bell ringer here. You knew him before the night of the lanterns.
Robert Newman: Yes. Paul was not a member of the congregation — he was Anglican enough to ring the bells but Presbyterian by preference, I think. He founded the bell ringers’ guild here and spent years mastering change ringing, which is a mathematical art of sorts: ringing a sequence of bells in patterns that never repeat. He and his guild spent countless hours in this building and up in that steeple. He knew the church nearly as well as I did. That familiarity was not an accident. Paul was always preparing for something, whether he knew exactly what or not.
Dan: Let’s talk about the plan for April 18th. Walk me through what you knew and when you knew it.
Robert Newman: Paul came to me beforehand — I will not say exactly how far beforehand, for reasons that were obvious at the time. He explained the situation. The British were preparing to march on Lexington and Concord to seize the colonial arms and supplies and to arrest the leaders of the resistance. The Sons of Liberty had riders ready to carry the warning overland. But the British were watching the roads. Riders could be stopped.
Dan: And the lanterns were the solution.
Robert Newman: The lanterns were the contingency. That is the word I would use, Dan. Not the solution — the contingency. The riders were the primary plan. The lanterns were what would save everything if the riders failed. One lantern if the British were marching by land. Two lanterns if they were crossing by sea, by water, through the harbor. The signal had to be brief — just long enough for the men watching from Charlestown across the water to see it. Long enough to read. Short enough that the British soldiers quartered in the neighborhood would not notice.
Dan: That was an enormous amount of pressure on one signal, on one moment, on one man.
Robert Newman: It was. And I will be honest with you — I understood the weight of it. If I failed, if I was too slow or too visible or if the men in Charlestown did not see the light, and if the riders were also stopped, the militias would have no warning. The British would arrive at Lexington and Concord before anyone was ready. The consequences of that I do not care to imagine.
Dan: How did you get into the church that night? The British had soldiers quartered in the neighborhood.
Robert Newman: Carefully. There were British soldiers staying in my own home at the time — my mother’s house. I waited until they had settled for the evening. Then I slipped out a window. I made my way through the streets to the church. I had a key. I knew every shadow of that building. I let myself in quietly, climbed the stairs to the steeple — all the way to the top — and hung the lanterns. Two of them. The British were crossing by water.
Dan: Two lanterns. And then?
Robert Newman: And then I took them down. As quickly as they had gone up. The signal was meant to last seconds, not minutes. Long enough to be seen. Short enough not to be investigated. I descended the steeple, secured the church, and made my way back through the streets.
Dan: And the riders? Paul Revere — what happened to him that night?
Robert Newman: He was stopped. The British detained him during the ride. He was questioned and held for a time before they released him — he managed to talk his way out of it, being Paul. By the time he was free, much of his part of the mission had been carried by others. William Dawes had ridden another route. Samuel Prescott, who joined them along the way, made it to Concord. The warning reached the militias. The colonists were ready when the British arrived at Lexington.
Dan: The backup plan worked.
Robert Newman: The backup plan worked. And I think that is the part of this story that gets lost in the poem and the legend. People hear about Paul’s ride and they imagine one heroic man on one horse carrying one message through the night. But what actually happened was more like a web. Multiple riders on multiple routes. A signal in a steeple as a contingency. A network of people, each knowing their role, each prepared to act if someone else could not. No single point of failure. That is not romance. But it is what actually saved the revolution that night.
Dan: Let me ask you about the church itself — before and beyond that night. It was a very divided place, wasn’t it? Loyalists and Patriots sitting in the same pews.
Robert Newman: Divided is one word for it. The Old North was an Anglican church — the Church of England, the official faith of the Crown. In a city full of Puritans and Congregationalists, that created a certain tension from the start. And then you had the social stratification inside the building itself: the wealthy families with their box pews near the altar, and up in the gallery above — the servants, the Black congregants, the children. The church that preached the equality of souls in front of God had arranged its seating to reflect something rather different.
Dan: And yet it was this church — this symbol of British authority — where the signal for the revolution was sent.
Robert Newman: Yes. I have thought about that more than once over the years. The highest steeple in Boston, built to remind the colonists of Crown authority, used to warn those same colonists that the Crown’s soldiers were on the march. There is a certain justice in it. Or perhaps just a certain practicality: it was the tallest point available, and the men who needed to send the signal knew it well. Sometimes history is less about symbolism and more about who has the key to the right building.
(Dan laughs)
Dan: What is the leadership lesson you would want people to take from your night in that steeple?
Robert Newman: Prepare before the crisis, not during it. I knew that steeple the way I knew my own hands — every step, every landing, every place where the wood creaked and where it did not. I did not climb it for the first time that night. I had been up there hundreds of times. When the moment came, there was no hesitation, no fumbling in the dark, no uncertainty. The preparation made the action possible.
Dan: And the backup plan itself — what does that teach us?
Robert Newman: That things go wrong. Always. The best-laid plan will encounter something its planners did not anticipate. Paul was stopped. Others were captured. The road to Concord was not what anyone expected it to be. A leader who stakes everything on a single path — who has no contingency, no fallback, no second option — is a leader who is one bad moment away from complete failure. The lanterns were not a sign of doubt in the riders. They were a sign of wisdom. You plan for success and prepare for the unexpected. Both at once.
Dan: And for someone who feels like their role is small — like they are the sexton, not the hero of the poem — what would you say to them?
Robert Newman: I would say that the poem is not the history. The poem is what people remember. The history is what actually happened. And what actually happened required someone who knew that building from ground to steeple top, who could move through the dark without making a sound, who could do their one specific job at exactly the right moment without anyone watching or applauding. Every mission has a Robert Newman. The question is whether that person is prepared when their moment arrives.
Dan: Robert Newman — the man who climbed the steeple. Thank you.
Robert Newman: It was two lanterns, Dan. That is all it took. Two lanterns and someone who knew the way up.
🏛️Travel in Time with Dan is where travel, history, and leadership come together.
Uncovering History. Inspiring Leadership.
📺 Watch the episode: YouTube | 🎙️ Listen to the podcast: Spotify | 📖 Read the blog: granddaddyssecrets.com | 📚 Dan’s book: Travel in Time in Connecticut
